In the wake of the recent DREAM Lightweight Grand Prix (I know it’s been over a week, but I’ve been busy) I’ve once again been left with a somewhat dry taste in my mouth regarding the final outcome. Once again in a Grand Prix, the best fighter didn’t win the tournament. This isn’t just a case of an upset happening because of wear and tear of a long tournament. In this case, the fighter who won the tournament was eliminated in the quarter finals. When Joachim Hansen came from the reserve match and then pounded out favourite Shinya Aoki (avenging a previous loss to Aoki via gogoplata at PRIDE Shockwave 2006), it got me thinking about whether the best fighter has ever won a Grand Prix?
Well of course it’s happened. Wanderlei Silva won the PRIDE 2003 Middleweight Grand Prix for one. Other then that though, in the traditional form that the Grand Prix is run under (where it all climaxes with a one night tournament) this is the only time that the tournament has run smoothly.
During the original PRIDE Grand Prix back in 2000, Mark Coleman advanced to the finals of the 8 man tournament after one fight (against middleweight journeyman Akira Shoji) to face Igor Vovchanchyn who had already fought Gary Goodridge and Kazushi Sakuraba that night. Coleman was meant to face Kazuyuki Fujita, but he withdrew after suffering a knee injury against Mark Kerr in the quarter finals.
Should Coleman have fought Fujita, its hard to imagine him being in the same shape going into the final. Fujita would have made Coleman work for the win (if he’d have even beaten him) and with Colemans known history to gas in fights that aren’t going his way (and also in fights that are going his way) it’s hard to imagine Coleman being as explosive as he was in the final. I’m not too upset about the result of this tournament though. It would have been nice for Igor to have something to recognise him being the top fighter in the World at that period of time, but Coleman winning was a great moment in MMA. However, this Grand Prix showed that the 8 man one night tournament isn’t a fair way of determining the best fighter in the World.
After this Grand Prix, PRIDE didn’t come back with another one until 2003. There, they changed the format, instead of starting with 16 fighters they used 8. This way the chances of fighters pulling out with injuries was reduced as they would only have to fight twice on the final night. This Grand Prix went off without a problem, and the best fighter won the tournament. Wanderlei Silva decisioned Hidehiko Yoshida in a war and then knocked out Quinton ‘Rampage’ Jackson (who earlier had stopped Chuck Liddell) to retain his spot as the best Middleweight (PRIDE calls Light Heavyweights, Middleweights for anyone who doesn’t know) in PRIDE. The format worked, the fights were all exciting, the Grand Prix was a huge success. PRIDE quickly begain work on another tournament that would take place 6 months after this one.
PRIDE returned in 2004 and quickly began hyping up their 2004 Grand Prix which was to include heavyweights. They again changed the format and would hold it over three events instead of two and use 16 fighters; combining the successful parts of the previous two GPs. The trouble with doing it this way is that the more fights you have during a Grand Prix, the more chances there are of something going wrong. In this Grand Prix it went wrong in the final fight. Throughout the early stages there were upsets (like Kevin Randleman knocking out Mirko Cro Cop with a punch), but nothing that couldn’t be attributed to the better fighter winning on the night.
What happened this time was a freak headclash during the final fight between Fedor Emelianenko and Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira that left the fans feeling empty and the tournament final a no contest. To be fair on the Grand Prix, the two squared off again at Shockwave 2004 with Fedor winning a unanimous decision, however the fact remains that the fans again felt unsatisfied with the finish of the Grand Prix.
2005 and it was time for the middleweights (light heavyweights) again. PRIDE again used 16 fighters over three events and after a great tournament it came down to Alistair Overeem, Mauricio ‘Shogun’ Rua, Ricardo Arona and Wanderlei Silva. Arona and Silva were to finally meet after Arona had been calling out Wanderlei for five years without a title shot. In the other bracket, should fellow Chute Boxe Academy fighter Mauricio Shogun, he could end up fighting the leader of Chute Boxe, Wanderlei Silva.
Now this could be classed as nitpicking, but I really think the real winner of this tournament left with a knockout loss to his name. Wanderlei Silva was finally defeated by a PRIDE middleweight for the first time in six years when Ricardo Arona outpointed him in the semi finals. However, instead of rejoicing with a victory over his longtime rival, he had to fight Shogun on the same night! I’m no big fan of Arona, but you have to feel for the guy. Shogun probably had the hardest road to the final, defeating Rampage, little Nogueira and Overeem to make the final, but Arona gets little credit for beating Wanderlei that night because of the loss to Shogun. Wanderlei then beat Arona by split decision at Shockwave 2005 to ‘retain’ his Middleweight title.
The same thing basically happened in 2006. Fedor Emelianenko withdrew from the Open Weight Grand Prix with an injury (and was replaced by Wanderlei Silva) and after the first two events of the tournament, Mirko Cro Cop, Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira, Josh Barnett and Wanderlei Silva were to fight it out at Final Conflict Absolute. Cro Cop drew Wanderlei Silva in the semi finals and Barnett would face Nogueira, with everyone expecting a long awaited rematch between Nogueira and Cro Cop to take place in the final.
Cro Cop eliminated Silva with a head kick and took his place in the final. In the other semi final, Josh Barnett and ‘Minotauro’ went to war. In what was a legendary ground fight between two big men, a final round kneebar attempt by Barnett, in which Nogueira was likely saved by the bell, probably won Barnett the decision. It was recognition at last for Barnett who had struggled in PRIDE after the steroid controversy following him winning the UFC Heavyweight title from Randy Couture. Instead though, Barnett would face Cro Cop that same night. Cro Cop would emerge as the winner of the tournament and enter the UFC with a lot of hype generated behind him (and then subsequently flop) while Barnett was left in relative obscurity and not given the respect he deserved after he as well lost a rematch against Nogueira at Shockwave 2006.
My last piece of evidence as to why the traditional Grand Prix format doesn’t work again comes from 2006 during the PRIDE Bushido Welterweight tournament. After defeating Kazuo Misaki in the semi finals by armbar, Paulo Filho was forced to withdraw due to a knee injury. The man to take his place and win the tournament? Kazuo Misaki! A fighter who lost in the semi finals (I guess it isn’t as stupid as the guy who lost in the quarter finals) is crowned the champion.
Now if you’re as hardcore a PRIDE fan as I am, you’d know that I left out two of PRIDE’s GPs. The 2005 Welterweight and Lightweight tournaments which were held over the PRIDE Bushido 9 and Shockwave 2005 events. The reason I left these tournaments out of my arguement is that they were run using a different format and a format that I think works really well. Instead of 16 fighters they used 8 like in the 2003 Middleweight Grand Prix.
The difference between this tournament and the 2003 Grand Prix is that instead of having the final four fighters fight twice on one night to decide the winner, they had the original eight fighters fight twice on one night to decide the finalists, then had them fight each other on the final night. This tournament was awesome, and the rightful winners were crowned. At Bushido 9, we had 12 fights between 16 of the top welterweights (PRIDE’s welterweight is everyone elses Middleweight) and lightweights. Then to finish it all off, the two best PRIDE Welterweights and Lightweights fought each other after suffering no wear and tear from a previous fight that night to decide who the best fighter really is.
I can only wonder why they haven’t run other Grand Prix like this? In fact, its mind boggling considered how popular this tournament was. The logic behind it is simple; the top fighters are less likely to be injured (and rendered useless in later rounds) because they are fighting lesser fighters on the night they have to fight twice. The anti-climax that has happened with so many Grand Prix is also less likely because you finish the tournament with the two best fighters fighting each other at a later date. I think this is something that should be considered if DREAM are to continue with the Grand Prix. In the end you want to see the best fighters fight each other, and the way most Grand Prix’s are run you just don’t get that.